3 Reasons Your Kids May Eventually Think Christianity is Worthless

3 Reasons Your Kids May Eventually Think Christianity is Worthless

During Vacation Bible School this summer, our church collected an offering to help an orphanage in Mexico. The kids were all encouraged to bring what they could to contribute toward the cause.

My daughter, age 7, has always been very generous with her allowance and came running down the stairs with a Ziploc bag of piggy bank money the morning after the collection was announced. I smiled with appreciation for her giving heart and told her, “I’m so proud of you. You always want to share your allowance with others. That’s wonderful, sweetheart.”

She looked at me, gave a slight shrug, and replied, “It’s JUST money I had in my piggy bank. It doesn’t really matter.”

My blood immediately went to a rolling boil. I have worked really hard to teach my kids the value of money and emphasize how grateful we need to be for every small thing we have. I couldn’t believe her cavalier attitude that morning.

I unsuccessfully tried to cover my deep annoyance and disappointment.

“You have got to be kidding me. I seriously can’t believe you just said that when we have talked so much about gratitude and generosity. That’s several dollars you have in that bag! How can you say it ‘doesn’t matter’?”

She looked down at the bag, which held two dollar bills and a bunch of coins. Then she looked at me in confusion and said, “MOMMY. This is not ‘several dollars.’ This is two dollars and a bunch of change that doesn’t matter.”

I took the bag and dumped everything out on our floor, then made piles of four quarters. I counted it all up and told her that she had $8.36.

She was shocked.

She scooped it all up, promptly put it back in the bag and announced there was “no way” she was giving away $8.36. Before I could launch into a sermon on generosity, she was halfway up the stairs looking for her piggy bank so she could deposit her newly found riches.

I’ve reflected several times on that experience, but not as much on the subject of generosity as on the subject of what it means to accurately value something.

There was $8.36 in that bag before and after our conversation. But something happened that drastically changed the value my daughter assigned to it—to the point that I couldn’t pry it out of her little hands just a few minutes later!

Similarly, Christianity is objectively true regardless of the value a person assigns to it. But something happens to many kids that fundamentally changes the value they place on it. Ultimately, the statistics show that at least 60% of kids reject faith by their early 20s…they decide it no longer has value. It literally becomes worthless.

Why the change? I think it boils down to three things.


1. They never understood how to value it.

My daughter ultimately didn’t know how to add up all the spare change in the bag. She could plainly see it all but didn’t know how to add all those different coins together. She just looked at the two dollar bills and assumed that’s all there was to the total value.

In a culture where people chalk religious belief up to nothing more than a person’s opinion about what may or may not exist beyond our natural world, most kids never learn how to appropriately value their religious beliefs. They don’t, by default, come to understand that:

  • Christianity is either true or it’s not. It’s an objective truth, and can’t be a matter of opinion. People may have different assessments of whether or not it’s true, but it’s not something that actually can be true for some and not others. When kids understand that, they’ll be more likely to value their faith because they’ll realize there’s much more at stake than a trivial matter of opinion. (For help talking to your kids about the nature of truth and Christianity in the context of other worldviews, see chapters 9-13 in my book, Keeping Your Kids on God’s Side.)
  • The truth of Christianity can be assessed by looking at evidence. Even if a person realizes that Christianity is ultimately an objective truth, they may place little value on committing to Christ because they believe there’s no real way of knowing Christianity is true. Our culture perpetuates the idea that faith is blind—a big leap in the dark. But that’s not the nature of biblical faith at all. Biblical faith is rooted in good reason (1 Peter 3:15). Again, kids don’t understand this by default. We have to shape their understanding so they know that they really can be confident that their decision for Christ is rooted in good reasons. That conviction makes all the difference in the world in how much a person values their faith.


2. They never had time to value it.

I’m guessing that if I had put my daughter in a room without distraction and plenty of time, she could have come close to totaling up the coins on her own. But between school, homework, piano lessons, soccer and chores, there’s no way such an exercise was going to get priority. She just didn’t have the time to appropriately value what was in the bag.

It’s really easy to play the victim when it comes to the perceived predator of time. I’m hugely guilty of this myself. “I have no time!” “I just wish there was more time!” “Where did the time go?” Those are things we all say. But the fact is, we all have the same number of hours in the day. It’s a matter of how we choose to use them. If your family’s spiritual life is crowded out by the constant shuttling between extracurricular activities, it’s time to really consider that. It might not be comfortable to look at it this way, but if we’re too busy to set aside family spiritual time at least once a week (for Bible study, faith conversations, prayer, etc.), we are quite literally choosing other activities over our kids’ spiritual growth.

It’s up to us to make time for them to learn to value their faith.


3. They forgot how to value it.

Last year, I actually had taught my kids how to add up coins of different values; there was a point in time when my daughter probably wouldn’t have been so cavalier with the money because she did know how to value it. But she forgot.

It’s easy to take for granted that whatever we taught our kids last month, last year, or three years ago is still part of their working knowledge. But planting seeds isn’t enough. We have to continually water them, tend to the growing soul, and plant more seeds. Otherwise, those earlier seedlings can easily be lost, and our kids can simply forget how to value what they may have know how to value in the past.


May we all help our kids develop a faith that they clutch like that Ziploc, realizing the surpassing worth of knowing Jesus Christ (Philippians 3:8).

8 thoughts on “3 Reasons Your Kids May Eventually Think Christianity is Worthless”

  1. I receive a lot of emails that have blogs on them, yet this one is the one I actually decide to read more consistently & with more enjoyment. I learn a lot as well as enjoy the writing style. I have read the book and enjoyed it immensely.

    Thank you for what you do.

  2. Children have two problems to overcome.

    First, they have inherited a faith. If they had been raised by Buddhist they would be Buddhists. Since they were raised by a particular denomination of Christians that is what they identify with.

    But as they age, at various times and in various ways, their faith should be challenged. In 1 Thess 5:21 we read, “Test everything; hold on to that which is good.” Good advice if you want your children to develop a faith that is their own. Ask them, in age-appropriate ways, why they believe in God. A wrong answer is, “because the Bible says we should”. Ask why they feel the Bible can be trusted. A wrong answer is “Because the preacher (or Bible teacher) said it can”.

    And the second problem has been called the “5th generation syndrome”. The 1st generation is excited and willing to sacrifice for some new concept they believe in. The 2nd generation witnessed that excitement and could speak first hand with those who initiated it. The 3rd generation appreciates what was done, but it comes to them largely as history. The 4th generation takes everything for granted. The 5th generation is indifferent/apathetic toward whatever the concept/idea was.

    This cycle needs to be broken. The history needs to be explained and brought to life with real names of real people suffering real problems. Once that is accomplished the cycle will have been reversed.

  3. Pingback: 3 Reasons Your Kids May Come To Think Christianity is Worthless – USSA News | The Tea Party's Front Page

  4. As a mom of two girls aged 4 and 2 I loved reading these thoughts. Thank you for providing me with inspiration on my journey of parenting. It’s a tough gig- installing values beyond transferring knowledge is a tricky one and I loved how you communicated the value of our own Christianity as well as generosity. Honest and heartfelt. Thank you. Xxx

  5. Pingback: My reading list for September 18-24, 2016 | Clay on the Wheel

  6. Very insightful. I think many adults, unfortunately, have the same struggle. As a natural giver, I ALWAYS have to assess whether my heart is truly tethered to the cause which I’m supporting…whether it’s financial support or a measure of time I’m dedicating to something/someone. When our hearts properly assess the value of that which we share, and still choose to humbly share, only then will we feel the magnitude of the loss and fullness of the gain that comes with following (and sharing) Christ.

    …may we always properly values our Christ.
    …may we always count up the cost, and still decide to go.
    …may we always have no threshold on that which we are willing to up for His sake.

  7. I think this insight is profound,concrete and points to which parents can easily relate As a speaker to Mom’s groups on Keep the Faith I have your book in my Bibliography The points you made here are so clear. As an author and Sunday School teacher of young children also my mission is geared toward helping parents connect their kids to Christ from an early age. Thank you for this blog and your book!

  8. Pingback: 3 Reasons Your Kids May Eventually Think Christianity is Worthless

Comments are closed.

Get Connected

Join more than 18,000 readers in receiving my 1-3 articles per month via email.